Lesson 6
Estimating Probabilities Using Simulation
6.1: Which One Doesn’t Belong: Spinners (5 minutes)
Warmup
This warmup prompts students to compare four images. It encourages students to explain their reasoning, hold mathematical conversations, and gives you the opportunity to hear how they use terminology and talk about characteristics of the images in comparison to one another. To allow all students to access the activity, each image has one obvious reason it does not belong. Encourage students to use appropriate terminology (eg The bottom left spinner is the only one with an outcome that has a probability greater than 0.5).
During the discussion, listen for important ideas and terminology that will be helpful in upcoming work of the unit.
Launch
Arrange students in groups of 2–4. Display the image for all to see. Ask students to indicate when they have noticed which image does not belong and can explain why. Give students 2 minutes of quiet think time and then time to share their thinking with their group. After everyone has conferred in groups, ask the group to offer at least one reason each image doesn’t belong. Follow with a wholeclass discussion.
Student Facing
Which spinner doesn't belong?
Student Response
For access, consult one of our IM Certified Partners.
Activity Synthesis
Ask each group to share one reason why a particular image does not belong. Record and display the responses for all to see. After each response, ask the class if they agree or disagree. Since there is no single correct answer to the question of which one does not belong, attend to students’ explanations and ensure the reasons given are correct. During the discussion, ask students to explain the meaning of any terminology they use, such as probability. Also, press students on unsubstantiated claims.
6.2: Diego’s Walk (20 minutes)
Activity
In this activity, students estimate the probability of a realworld event by simulating the experience with a chance experiment (MP4). Students see that that multiple simulation methods can result in similar estimates for the probability of the actual event.
Launch
Arrange students in groups of 3. Prepare each group with supplies for 1 type of simulation: choosing a slip from a bag, spinning a spinner, or rolling 2 number cubes. The supplies for each of these simulations include:
 a bag containing a set of slips from the blackline master
 a spinner cut from the blackline master, a pencil and a paper clip
 2 standard number cubes
Set up the following simulation by telling the students: Diego must cross a busy intersection at a crosswalk on his way to school. Some days he is able to cross immediately or wait only a short while. Other days, he must wait for more than 1 minute for the signal to indicate he may cross the street. We will simulate his luck at this intersection using different methods and estimate his probability of waiting more than 1 minute.
Teacher note: The bag of papers and spinner are designed to have a probability of 0.7 to wait more than 1 minute. The number cubes have a probability of approximately 0.72 to wait more than 1 minute. To the extent that the students are estimating the probabilities, these are close enough to give similar results.
Give students 15 minutes for group work followed by a wholeclass discussion.
Supports accessibility for: Conceptual processing; Organization
Student Facing
Your teacher will give your group the supplies for one of the three different simulations. Follow these instructions to simulate 15 days of Diego’s walk. The first 3 days have been done for you.

Simulate one day:

If your group gets a bag of papers, reach into the bag, and select one paper without looking inside.

If your group gets a spinner, spin the spinner, and see where it stops.

If your group gets two number cubes, roll both cubes, and add the numbers that land face up. A sum of 2–8 means Diego has to wait.


Record in the table whether or not Diego had to wait more than 1 minute.

Calculate the total number of days and the cumulative fraction of days that Diego has had to wait so far.

On the graph, plot the number of days and the fraction that Diego has had to wait. Connect each point by a line.

If your group has the bag of papers, put the paper back into the bag, and shake the bag to mix up the papers.

Pass the supplies to the next person in the group.
day  Does Diego have to wait more than 1 minute? 
total number of days Diego had to wait 
fraction of days Diego had to wait 

1  no  0  \(\frac{0}{1} =\) 0.00 
2  yes  1  \(\frac{1}{2} =\) 0.50 
3  yes  2  \(\frac{2}{3} \approx\) 0.67 
4  
5  
6  
7  
8  
9  
10  
11  
12  
13  
14  
15 

Based on the data you have collected, do you think the fraction of days Diego has to wait after the 16th day will be closer to 0.9 or 0.7? Explain or show your reasoning.

Continue the simulation for 10 more days. Record your results in this table and on the graph from earlier.
day Does Diego have
to wait more
than 1 minute?total number
of days Diego
had to waitfraction
of days Diego
had to wait16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25  What do you notice about the graph?
 Based on the graph, estimate the probability that Diego will have to wait more than 1 minute to cross the crosswalk.
Student Response
For access, consult one of our IM Certified Partners.
Student Facing
Are you ready for more?
Let's look at why the values tend to not change much after doing the simulation many times.

After doing the simulation 4 times, a group finds that Diego had to wait 3 times. What is an estimate for the probability Diego has to wait based on these results?
 If this group does the simulation 1 more time, what are the two possible outcomes for the fifth simulation?
 For each possibility, estimate the probability Diego has to wait.
 What are the differences between the possible estimates after 5 simulations and the estimate after 4 simulations?

After doing the simulation 20 times, this group finds that Diego had to wait 15 times. What is an estimate for the probability Diego has to wait based on these results?
 If this group does the simulation 1 more time, what are the two possible outcomes for the twentyfirst simulation?
 For each possibility, estimate the probability Diego has to wait.
 What are the differences between the possible estimates after 21 simulations and the estimate after 20 simulations?

Use these results to explain why a single result after many simulations does not affect the estimate as much as a single result after only a few simulations.
Student Response
For access, consult one of our IM Certified Partners.
Activity Synthesis
The purpose of this discussion is for students to understand why simulations are useful in place of actual experiments.
Select at least one group for each of the simulation methods to display the materials they used to run their simulation and explain the steps involved in using their materials.
Ask students, "Why do you think these simulations are more useful than actually doing the experiment many times?" (It would take a lot of time and work for Diego to walk to school more than usual, but it is easy to do the simulation many times quickly.)
Select students to share what they noticed about the graph of the fraction of days Diego had to wait as the simulated days went on.
6.3: Designing Experiments (10 minutes)
Activity
In this activity, students have the opportunity to design their own simulations that could be used to estimate probabilities of reallife events (MP4). Students attend to precision (MP6) by assigning each possible outcome for the reallife experiment to a corresponding outcome in their simulation in such a way that the pair of outcomes have the same probability. In the discussion following the activity, students are asked to articulate how these simulations could be used to estimate probabilities of certain events.
Launch
Keep students in groups of 3. Give students 5 minutes quiet work time to design their own experiments, followed by smallgroup discussion to compare answers for the situations and wholeclass discussion.
As students work, monitor for students who are using the same chance events for multiple scenarios (for example, always using a spinner) and encourage them to think about other ways to simulate the event.
Supports accessibility for: Organization; Attention; Socialemotional skills
Student Facing
For each situation, describe a chance experiment that would fairly represent it.

Six people are going out to lunch together. One of them will be selected at random to choose which restaurant to go to. Who gets to choose?

After a robot stands up, it is equally likely to step forward with its left foot or its right foot. Which foot will it use for its first step?

In a computer game, there are three tunnels. Each time the level loads, the computer randomly selects one of the tunnels to lead to the castle. Which tunnel is it?

Your school is taking 4 buses of students on a field trip. Will you be assigned to the same bus that your math teacher is riding on?
Student Response
For access, consult one of our IM Certified Partners.
Anticipated Misconceptions
Students may think that the number of outcomes in the sample space must be the same in the simulation as in the reallife situation. Ask students how we could use the results from the roll of a standard number cube to represent a situation with only two equally likely outcomes. (By making use of some extra options to count as "roll again.")
Activity Synthesis
The purpose of this discussion is for students to think more deeply about the connections between the reallife experiment and the simulation.
Select partners to share the simulations they designed for each of the situations.
Some questions for discussion:
 "How could a standard number cube be used to simulate the situation with the buses?" (Each bus is assigned a number 1 through 4. If the cube ends on 5 or 6, roll again.)
 "If one of the buses was numbered with your math teacher's favorite number and you wanted to increase the probability of that bus being selected, how could you change the simulation to do this?" (Add more of the related outcome. For example, using the standard number cube as in the previous discussion question, the bus with the favorite number could be assigned numbers 4 and 5 while the other buses are still 1 through 3.)
 Two of the tunnels in the video game lead to a swamp that ends the game. How could you use your simulation to estimate the probability of choosing one of those two tunnels? (Since all of the tunnels are equally likely to lead to the swamp, it can be assumed that "left" and "right" lead to the swamp. Spin the spinner many times and use the fraction of times it ends on "left" or "right" to estimate the probability of ending the game. It should happen \(\frac{2}{3}\) or about 67% of the time.)
 "You and a friend are among the people going to lunch. How could you use the simulation you designed to estimate the probability that you or your friend will be the one to choose the restaurant?" (My friend and I will be represented by 1 and 2 on a number cube. Roll the number cube a lot of times and find the fraction of times 1 or 2 appear, then estimate the probability that we will be the ones selected.)
Design Principle(s): Support sensemaking, Cultivate conversation
Lesson Synthesis
Lesson Synthesis
Consider asking these discussion questions:
 "What is a simulation?"
 "Why might you want to run a simulation rather than the actual event?" (Simulations are easier and usually faster to do multiple times, so using them to get an estimate of the probability of an event is sometimes preferred.)
 "If you conduct a few trial simulations of a situation and record the the fraction of outcomes for which a particular event occurs, how might you know that you have done enough simulations to have a good estimate of the probability of that event happening?" (When the fractions seem to not be changing very much based on how accurate you want your estimate to be.)
6.4: Cooldown  Video Game Weather (5 minutes)
CoolDown
For access, consult one of our IM Certified Partners.
Student Lesson Summary
Student Facing
Sometimes it is easier to estimate a probability by doing a simulation. A simulation is an experiment that approximates a situation in the real world. Simulations are useful when it is hard or timeconsuming to gather enough information to estimate the probability of some event.
For example, imagine Andre has to transfer from one bus to another on the way to his music lesson. Most of the time he makes the transfer just fine, but sometimes the first bus is late and he misses the second bus. We could set up a simulation with slips of paper in a bag. Each paper is marked with a time when the first bus arrives at the transfer point. We select slips at random from the bag. After many trials, we calculate the fraction of the times that he missed the bus to estimate the probability that he will miss the bus on a given day.